Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr Jane Olivier - MBChB's avatar

Dear Julia,

I really enjoyed your post and behalf of some innocently uninformed doctors, I apologize when we thought we knew or had been taught it all.

I qualified as a doctor in Durban South Africa 2005 so I've been a doctor for almost 20 years.

Here is a secret I'm not sure I should write out loud....during our 8 years of training not once was I taught about (and I will suggest books for you to empower yourself):

- Sleep (Why We Sleep - Professor Matt Walker)

- How to prescribe a nutritional plan (we were shown the food pyramid which I only discovered this past year is absolutely and horribly WRONG) - (The Obesity Code - Dr Jason Fung, and Fast Like A Girl - Dr Mindy Pelz)

- How to prescribe exercise

- Calorie counting and restriction is a big fail

- Move more eat less is a fail

- How the food industry has knowingly made the foods we eat addictive

I highly recommend you read "The Obesity Code" by Dr Jason Fung, who also has videos on YouTube regarding how to reverse diabetes (yes, it can be completely REVERSED which is something we were also never taught at med school), and how to treat metabolic syndrome (obesity, low HDL cholesterol, high triglycerides, high blood pressure, insulin resistance aka blood sugar problems), the latter which we were also only briefly taught about.

Every 2 years Emergency Doctors like myself have to update our International Certification with the American Heart Association to perform cardiac resuscitation's. These courses are expensive and expire every 2 years.

After having attended probably 10 repeats of these internationally accredited courses in the past 20 years I've been practicing as a doctor, I've been getting progressively frustrated at the lack of prevention of the cardiac arrest which in part has lead me to seek out my own knowledge, only to discover how we as doctors have not been taught adequately despite the science and research being available.

Doctor heal thy self. Aging is not a "normal" process (for more on this please read "Outlive - Dr Peter Attia). For too long we've accepted aging and chronic disease as the norm.

There is now well researched information out there accessible to everyone. Go forth and conquer and by all means, please politely challenge us doctors when in doubt (perhaps ask them how many hours they have slept before challenging them or else anticipate grumpiness).

The great thing about being wrong is that it's a learning experience. After all, that is why we call medicine a practice, and at the end of the day I think I speak for most of us in the medical profession, we are all doing our best with the knowledge, time and resources that we have been given.

Kind and mad regards,

Mad Madagascan Mum & Medic (who's just trying to be her own hero)

Jane

Expand full comment
Marlo Leaman's avatar

Awesome article Julia! I have just purchased the book and can't wait to read it! I am a believer that we have to advocate for our own health and follow many integrative and functional doctors. I wish doctors would not succumb to the 'traditional' way of medicine and be influenced by big Pharma and the big hospital networks that tell them to spend no more than 15 minutes with patients. Crazy! We know our bodies best and I like your statement that 'doctor' means teacher and with their input and them listening to ours, we can best work for our better health!

Expand full comment
29 more comments...

No posts